Theater Digest - November 26, 2019

Hi, I'm Katie! I see a lot of theater. And when I say "a lot," I mean a lot. In 2018, I saw 58 shows in L.A., 5 shows in New York, and 5 shows in London. I used to be a theater critic for LA Weekly, and I still write the occasional theater review for Stage Raw. 

These are my subjective opinions—there's a good chance you won't agree with what I think about any particular show, but if you don't think I've defended my stance on a show well enough, let me know, and I'll be happy to give more context. 

As a rule, I won't be talking about any Disney shows. Since this newsletter is geared towards people in the entertainment industry, there's a good chance I won't like a show that you or someone you know was involved in. I'm sure that you/your friend put a lot of effort into your/their work! I've been in a few shows, I know how much work goes into putting on a show. But just as you're entitled to dislike TV shows your friends worked on, I'm allowed to dislike theater you/your friends may have worked on. I try not to be vindictive, but I also do make it clear when I don't think a show is worth the price of a ticket or the time spent watching it. 

I won't be writing much/any synopsis in these blurbs, but feel free to check out other reviews for synopses! Or just check out other reviews in general! Keep theater journalism alive & well! 

Each week, I'll remove everything that’s closed, and put ** next to anything that’s new!

Worth Seeing:

Waitress on Broadway & the West End [NY/London]. I love this show! So much. I think it was really done a disservice by opening in the same theater season as Hamilton—any other year, it would have easily won Best Musical and plenty of other awards. This show is so good and so well done on every level! I think it’s the kind of show that will appeal to people who don’t love musicals, too. 
Based on a movie distributed by Fox Searchlight.
Closes Jan 5 in NY and July 4 in London.
My full review: http://stageraw.com/2018/08/07/waitress-theater-review/

School Girls; or, the African Mean Girls Play on PBS [NY] (it's online, but you can only watch it if the PBS website thinks you're in the New York City area). I reallllly liked this! I liked the script, and I liked seeing it staged even more. Sometimes Important plays are not good or enjoyable; this is an Important play that is also good and enjoyable. This is a filmed version of the off-Broadway production from last year, which should be identical to what I saw when it was in L.A. last fall.
Link to watch: https://www.thirteen.org/programs/theater-close-up/school-girls-or-the-african-mean-girls-play-ocalhd/
My full review: http://stageraw.com/2018/09/11/school-girls-or-the-african-mean-girls-play-theater-review/

A mixed bag:

The Great Leap at the Pasadena Playhouse [LA]. Lauren Yee is a phenomenally talented playwright, and the text of this play is so gracefully written. I imagine it makes a great read. However, I found the direction and a couple of the performances in this production to be rather lacking. The text is good enough (especially in the final moments of the play, which are astounding) that it buoys the production as a whole, but those shortcomings prevent me from fully recommending seeing it.
Closes Dec. 1 in LA.
My full review: http://stageraw.com/2019/11/19/the-great-leap/

The Inheritance on Broadway [NY] (reviewed in London last November). This is an extremely ambitious work—a sprawling adaptation of Howard’s End, set across six acts, seven hours, and two plays. This telling of E.M. Forster’s book, which was published in 1910, is set in the present day, and (almost) all of the characters are gay men. A recurring theme is the lost generation of gay men who died in the AIDS epidemic, and the way the play portrays this is beautiful and haunting—in particular, the last scene of the first play is one of the most stunning moments I’ve ever seen on stage. And indeed, the first four hours of this play are quite good! And I commend the writer, Matthew Lopez, and director, Stephen Daldry, for keeping things interesting for four hours, that’s no easy task. But there are still three more hours after those first four, and those become less enjoyable as the play becomes more recursive and less grounded. Overall, the work is quite good, there’s just too much of it. I would honestly say that you could probably get away with seeing just Part 1, and skip Part 2.
Open-ended run in NY.

Come From Away on Broadway [NY]. My expectations going into this were pretty low, and the show exceeded them, but it didn’t win me over. The story is good, but because 9/11 plays such an important role in it, it’s at odds with the musical form. Also, the songs weren’t that good. The music was passable, but the lyrics were poor, over-relying on rhyming couplets, and, failing that, leaving lone lines to land with a thud. The book (the scenes between songs) was charming enough, and the whole thing was well-directed and -acted, but I couldn’t get into it. The book, music, and lyrics are all credited to the same two writers, so it’s hard to separate out individual elements.
This is set up at eOne.
Open-ended run in NY.

Dear Evan Hansen on Broadway [NY]. I originally saw this right after it opened on Broadway, and loved it then, loved it much less the second time, but I think it’s still worth seeing once, if you can afford the ticket price. If you can’t, don’t fret too much.
This is set up at Universal.
Closed in LA (back next season); open-ended run in NY
My original review of the Broadway production: https://www.pastemagazine.com/articles/2017/01/review-dear-evan-hansen.html
My full review of the production at the Ahmanson: http://stageraw.com/2018/10/24/dear-evan-hansen-theater-review/

Ain’t Too Proud on Broadway [NY] (reviewed at the Ahmanson last August). I wanted to like this. I mean, it’s a musical based on the Temptations! Great songs. And the musical performances are realllllly good! But the show as a whole is uneven, thanks to a lackluster book. The director, Des McAnuff, who also directed Jersey Boys and Jesus Christ Superstar on Broadway, seems to be falling into a visual shtick, but it didn’t bother me too much here. 
Note: this may have undergone development between the LA and New York runs, but I still wouldn't be inclined to see it a second time.
Open-ended run in NY. 
My full review: http://stageraw.com/2018/08/28/aint-too-proud-theater-review/

Not worth it:

**Love Actually, Live at the Wallis [LA] (Reviewed last December). This is a “For the Record” show, if you’ve ever seen one of those before; they project scenes from a beloved movie and intercut the scenes with songs that were in or adjacent to the movie at the time of its release, performed live. So it plays in 5 minute bursts: projected scene, live song, scene, song, ad infinitum (or nearly—this one clocks in at almost three hours). Fun fact, these For the Record shows were quite illegal in their early days, they never licensed any of the content they used, but I guess they’ve worked that out now. The cast here are all good singers, but due to the form of the show, they don’t have a ton to do. The show blasts you with nostalgia, and perhaps that’s effective for Love Actually superfans, but for anyone who’s less than a superfan, it will likely leave you wanting something of substance.
Closes Dec 29 in LA.

**Between Riverside and Crazy at the Fountain [LA]. Nothing about this play or production really worked for me, but I recognize that I’m in the minority, because I know a lot of people liked it. Maybe the cast was off at the performance I saw—there were certainly quite a few flubbed lines, which I found surprising over a month into the run. All the actors felt like they were in productions of this play that were independent of each other; it didn’t feel cohesive. The writing was fine (the play won the Pulitzer in 2015), and while it’s great that the playwright is centering black and Latinx protagonists, it felt off to me, since the playwright is from neither community, and at times, he seems to be manipulating the characters of color in ways that reinforce the white characters’ (and potentially a white audience’s) negative perceptions of those characters.
Closes Jan. 26 in LA.

Key Largo at the Geffen [LA]. This play didn’t work for me on any level. The cast was lackluster, and Andy Garcia, who I’ve liked in many film & TV roles, feels miscast here. The writing also wasn’t particularly compelling. It’s based on the old WB film noir, but I didn’t find myself caring about any of the characters, and I spent most of the show dreading the next gunshot, since gun violence figures prominently into the play.
Closes Dec. 10 in LA.

Neil Simon’s Musical Fools in Atwater Village [LA]. Full disclosure, I was in a production of Neil Simon’s (non-musical) Fools in high school. I had a very small role that I don’t think was even called for in the script (“Townsperson”) and I am probably over-estimating the quality of our production, but I remember the play being pretty funny—lots of old-school, malapropism- & pun-based humor. I found this production, with added/new songs, to be pretty devoid of humor. The text of the play, as far as I can tell, is still amusing, but the songs really took me out of it. Some of them feature new lyrics, while others seem to have Simon’s original dialogue forced into musical phrases that don’t accommodate the syllabic content therein. I wasn’t blown away by the performances, but most of the leads at the performance I saw were understudies.
Closes Dec. 1 in LA.

The Thanksgiving Play at the Geffen [LA]. As it happens, this play has a nearly identical structure to We Are Proud to Present…, which I previously strongly recommended. I don’t think that structure works as well here—this play, written by an indigenous playwright, is about a bunch of white people trying to devise a play about indigenous peoples. White Feminism (tm) can be insufferable, which this play demonstrates quite well, I’m just not that interested in watching a show about navel-gazing snakes eating their own tails. The production itself is quite well done, it’s just the concept that I think is a misfire.
Closes Dec. 1 in LA.

On my radar:

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child in London/NY/San Francisco. The time commitment and ticket cost have kept me from seeing this one so far. 
Hadestown on Broadway 
Oklahoma! on Broadway 
Moulin Rouge! on Broadway
Slave Play on Broadway

Upcoming shows I'm seeing: 

& Juliet on the West End + TBD London shows
Frozen at the Pantages (I won’t be writing about this one)

If you were forwarded this email and would like to receive updates (more or less) weekly, click the button below!